The Beis hamikdash
  • Beis Hamikdash posts
  • sources
    • Mishnayos Middos >
      • משניות מדות עם מפרשים
      • משניות זכר חנוך
      • English Mishnayos Middos
      • Ezras Kohanim part 1
      • Ezras Kohanim part 2
      • Beis Hamiddos
    • Gemarah
    • Rambam >
      • Rambam (with נושאי כלים)
      • Lubavitcher Rebbe's Biurim
      • מעשי למלך על משנה תורה
      • likutey rambam
      • Derech Chochmah (R' Chaim Kanievski)
    • Rishonim
    • Sha'alos Uteshuvos HaRaDVaZ
    • Shiltey Hagibborim
    • Chanukas Habayis (both) and biur Maharam Kazis on middos
    • diagrams >
      • R' Yehoshua Ibn Gaon's map
      • Tosfos Yom Tov's diagram
      • Reb Yehonasan's diagram
      • Tiferes Yisroel's diagram
      • Lubavitcher rebbe's edits to a diagram of the Beis Hamikdash
    • Tavnis Heichal
    • Be'er Hagolah
    • Binyan Ariel
    • Shevet Yehudah
    • other
    • Braisa D'Meleches Hamishkan
    • Sefarim on the Mishkan
    • Third Beis Hamikdash sefarim
    • from Josephus-יוסיפון >
      • Antiquities of the jews 8:3
      • Antiquities of the Jews 15:11
      • war of the Jews
      • Yosifun יוסיפון
    • קובץ מעלין בקדש
    • Kuntres Klei Hamikdash
  • Gallery
  • videos
    • First Beis Hamikdash
    • second Beis Hamikdash videos
    • Third Beis Hamikdash videos
    • avodah videos
  • 1st Beis Hamikdash
  • 3rd Beis Hamikdash
  • virtual walkthroughs
    • First Beis Hamikdash
    • Third Beis Hamikdash
    • Second Beis Hamikdash (Pre-Herodian)
  • 3d models
  • Lego Gallery
  • diagram of Mizbeach
  • contact

Did the Rambam enter Har Habayis? (updated)

4/5/2022

1 Comment

 
Picture
   In a previous post, I tried bringing a proof that the dome of the rock is the place of the Kodesh Hakodoshim from the fact that the Rambam went onto Har Habayis. However, the Rambam does not state clearly that he went onto Har Habayis. He writes (quoted in Sefer Hacharedim מצוות התלויות בארץ פ"ג)  "on the fourth day of the month of Cheshvan... We left from Acco to go up to Yerushalayim, under danger, and I went into the great and holy house, and I davened there. This is usually explained to mean the Har Habayis, the place of the great and holy house of Hashem, however, it can also be referring to a Shul, especially a Shul next to Har Habayis,  so the Rambam can be referring to that.
  In Kovetz Ma'alin BaKodesh, issue 37, (pp 93) ר' אמיחי אליאש brings a letter from R' Avraham, the Rambam's son, where he says that the Rambam, when writing the Sefer Hamitzvos, might have held that someone who is Tamey from a corpse is not allowed to go on the whole Har Habayis, although when he wrote the Mishneh Torah, he changed his mind. Based on this, we see that the Rambam might have held at the time of his going to Yerushalayim, that no Tamey person can go on Har Habayis at all, so he for sure could not have gone onto it. (You can still say that the Rambam went onto the part of Har Habayis that was added by Hurdus, which is not holy, and the Rambam calculated the boundaries of the holy Har Habayis based on the dome of the rock, but there is no proof from this letter.)

   ​However, in the next issue of Ma'alin Bakodesh.  R' Azaryah Ariel brings the Rambam in Peirush Hamishnayos Keilim 1:8, (which was written before Sefer Hamitzvos, and after the Rambam was in Eretz Yisrael,) where he writes clearly that a someone who is Tamey from a corpse is allowed to go on the Har Habayis. Based on this, he says that originally the Rambam held you could go up if you are Tamey from a corpse, but at some point, between writing Peirush Hamishnayos and Sefer Hamitzvos, he changed his mind and held it is forbidden, and then later, when he wrote Mishneh Torah, he went back to his earlier opinion that it is allowed. (ר' אמיחי אליאש responds to R' Azaryah Ariel in that same issue of Ma'alin Bakodesh, and then R' Azaryah Ariel answers back,)
1 Comment
No Strings Attached Ottawa link
7/28/2025 08:21:53 pm

I find this analysis about Rambam’s writings very insightful.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Website updates

    I have added the commentaries קב ונקי and זרע ישראל to the משניות מדות עם מפרשים page.

    Categories

    All
    Avodos
    Explaning My Model
    First Beis Hamikdash
    Heichal
    Location Of Beis Hamikdash
    Original Second Mikdash
    Other
    Other Research
    The Azarah
    The Outer Walls Of The Har Habayis
    Under The Har Habayis
    Yerushalayim

    Archives

    February 2024
    January 2024
    September 2023
    June 2023
    April 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    May 2021
    April 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020

    RSS Feed

    Author

    My name is Mendel Lewis.
    ​I live in Brooklyn, NY. 

     Hashem said to Yechezkel, "Its reading in the Torah is as great as its building. Go and say it to them, and they will occupy themselves to read the form of it in the Torah. And in reward for its reading, that they occupy themselves to read about it, I count it for them as if they were occupied with the building of it. (Tanchuma tzav 14)
Proudly powered by Weebly
Photos from David Jones, xiquinhosilva, hoyasmeg
  • Beis Hamikdash posts
  • sources
    • Mishnayos Middos >
      • משניות מדות עם מפרשים
      • משניות זכר חנוך
      • English Mishnayos Middos
      • Ezras Kohanim part 1
      • Ezras Kohanim part 2
      • Beis Hamiddos
    • Gemarah
    • Rambam >
      • Rambam (with נושאי כלים)
      • Lubavitcher Rebbe's Biurim
      • מעשי למלך על משנה תורה
      • likutey rambam
      • Derech Chochmah (R' Chaim Kanievski)
    • Rishonim
    • Sha'alos Uteshuvos HaRaDVaZ
    • Shiltey Hagibborim
    • Chanukas Habayis (both) and biur Maharam Kazis on middos
    • diagrams >
      • R' Yehoshua Ibn Gaon's map
      • Tosfos Yom Tov's diagram
      • Reb Yehonasan's diagram
      • Tiferes Yisroel's diagram
      • Lubavitcher rebbe's edits to a diagram of the Beis Hamikdash
    • Tavnis Heichal
    • Be'er Hagolah
    • Binyan Ariel
    • Shevet Yehudah
    • other
    • Braisa D'Meleches Hamishkan
    • Sefarim on the Mishkan
    • Third Beis Hamikdash sefarim
    • from Josephus-יוסיפון >
      • Antiquities of the jews 8:3
      • Antiquities of the Jews 15:11
      • war of the Jews
      • Yosifun יוסיפון
    • קובץ מעלין בקדש
    • Kuntres Klei Hamikdash
  • Gallery
  • videos
    • First Beis Hamikdash
    • second Beis Hamikdash videos
    • Third Beis Hamikdash videos
    • avodah videos
  • 1st Beis Hamikdash
  • 3rd Beis Hamikdash
  • virtual walkthroughs
    • First Beis Hamikdash
    • Third Beis Hamikdash
    • Second Beis Hamikdash (Pre-Herodian)
  • 3d models
  • Lego Gallery
  • diagram of Mizbeach
  • contact